What's new ?
Second Co-Creation activities with end-users
The end-user organisations involved in the project in Switzerland and Romania conducted workshops and heuristic evaluations in August 2020 to evaluate the status of the application. The goal was to get feedback on the current interface design of the CoachMyLife application in terms of usability and accessibility before the start of the first field tests in the real user environment. In addition to seniors aged 65+ as primary users, medical experts, caregivers and further usability experts were involved in the evaluation.
An evaluation by experts provides feedback on how a product or concept idea can be optimised. Therefore, we have used the method of heuristic evaluation for gaining feedback of medical experts and caregivers. In order to involve seniors in the co-designing process, workshops in the end-user organisations were originally planned. In Switzerland they were conducted remotely by using the virtual meeting tool “GoToMeeting” since we wanted to prioritise telematic contact over face-to-face interactions in order to protect the seniors due to the Covid19 pandemic.
The results of the expert evaluation and the senior's feedback were very positive and helpful. The structure of the app appears to be understandable for both experts and seniors. The application was found to be very helpful for future users as long as individuality and adaptability to the user's needs are taken into account. Data protection is also an issue that concerns seniors nowadays. Therefore, steps are being taken in the project to create a trustworthy system that will meet with great acceptance by future users.
Thanks to the great participation of end-users and healthcare professionals, important insights for the further development of the CML application could be gained. This brings the project team closer to a solution that creates real added value and wants to be used by the target group.
3rd "in-person" Meeting
Because of the pandemic, the in-person meeting was canceled and the partners met virtually. However, each partner has been able to make a presentation and a demonstration of what had been achieved during the lockdown.
The home-office didn't impact the progress of the CML solution and the technical partners have been very creative:
- JSI tested the Computer Vision at home
- PPSA and UNIGE elaborated a video for the ERT smart pill dispenser utilisation
- TERZ organised a virtual workshop with end-users
- CTI worked on the CML application
- UMFCD finalised the study protocol
Given the COVID19 pandemic and its uncertain evolution, the Consortium decided to postpone the first pilot phase to mid-October 2020.
The next in-person meeting will hopefully be maintained in Slovenia, beginning of December 2020...
2. During the setup, the user can manually select some areas and objects of interest in the room.
The algorithm for detecting the activity of drinking is now working !
JSI is in charge of developing computer vision for hydration activities. The whole process is organised this way:
6. After being alerted, the system analyzes for some time what the user is doing, and checks if they are drinking or not.
If they don’t drink for too long of a time, the tablet will receive a notification...better to get some water!
1. A camera will be placed next to the ceiling of the kitchen, in order to observe the whole room.
3. The camera observes the scene, and nothing happens as long as the user is just wandering around.
4. However, if the user steps inside one of the selected areas, or touches ones of the selected objects, the program is alerted that it’s time to get to work!
5. One of the situations that will alert the system is the displacement of the CoachMyLife mug.
How will our solution help users take their medication ?
An automatic pill dispenser is a perfect solution for patients suffering from cognitive impairment or mild dementia, mentally or visually impaired patients, or patients who need to take multiple different medications and need notifications when certain medications have to be taken.
The automatic pill dispenser can be filled with a supply of pills that lasts between one week and one month, depending on the number of daily doses. A loud acoustic signal announces the treatment needs to be taken. Only the specific pills are available to the patient, as previously set in the dosing area.
If the medication is not taken at the set time, it is safely stored in a locked tablet dispenser.
How will our solution detect eating ?
Understanding the dietary habits of people plays a crucial role in interventions promoting a healthy lifestyle. People with mild cognitive impairment and dementia require monitoring of their eating behaviour because they often forget whether they have already eaten. As a result, they eat lunch or dinner multiple times a day or not at all, which might cause additional health problems. Proper treatment of these issues requires an objective measurement of the time at which the meal takes place, the duration of the meal and what the person eats.
For this purpose, we are developing an eating-detection method using a wristband. Wristband devices and smartwatches are increasingly popular, mainly because people are accustomed to wearing watches, which makes the wrist placement one of the least intrusive placements to wear a device. Additionally, the cost of these devices can be relatively small, which makes them easily accessible to everyone.
Our method works with motion data from an accelerometer and gyroscope sensors. Using these two sensors, we are able to monitor the movement of the hand, from which we can extract information whether eating takes place. The method makes a decision using an advanced AI algorithm. Additionally, our eating-detection method is energy-efficient, which means that even though the wristband is a device with limited battery life, it will be able to run the advanced method without significantly affecting the battery. At the moment, our method detects periods and duration of eating. However, in the near future, we also plan to focus on detecting bites.
What are the Hometab functionalities ?
The HomeTab is a desktop based touch-screen IP-based carephone specially adapted both from hardware and software sides for it's end users (mostly elderly people, not having much technology skills).
Those are all the possible functionalities, but some of them will be used in CML pilot. The CML application will be managed through the HomeTab developed and provided by Eurotronik.
Functionalities for users:
• Emergency call that can be routed to formal or informal caregivers
• Service calls (request for cleaning, food ordering)
• Smart-home management (switching on-off lights, heating, curtains …)
• Reminders and appointments (birthdays, doctor appointments, medications …)
• Video calls (with family, friends …)
• Playing games
• Possible integration of other apps / platforms
Functionalities for caregivers:
• List of pending / requested tasks to perform at the user (elderly)
• Documentation of all services done at / to the user (health-care related and other, such as cleaning, food delivery)
• History of tasks accomplished
Which devices will be used to detect the identified activities and send the right reminder at the right time ?
Our partner Eurotronik provides professional ICT solutions for nursing homes, hospitals, and other care facilities, as well as for elderly individuals who feel the need for independent living, more efficient communication and want to simplify their everyday activities with this kind of systems.
For the pilot phases, three devices will be provided to the participants:
- A tablet (Hometab) with the CML application
- A wristband
- A smart pill dispenser
2nd in-person Meeting (Sinaia - Romania)
The UMFCD team welcomed the Consortium and allowed the partners to discover a beautiful region, after long days of brainstorming and decision making.
Activities which will be recognised through computer vision have been identified, the inclusion criteria for the participants to our first pilot phase were defined and a prototype of the application has been shown by CTI.
Among the activities which have been enunciated by the participants of the TERZ first Co-creation workshop, four have been chosen by the CML partners:
4. Teeth brushing
The Computer vision will recognise the activity and allow the CML solution to provide the adequate reminder to the user.
Next stop: Slovenia in summer 2020...
First Co-Creation Workshop with end-users
In November 2019, initial workshops were carried out with seniors at terzStiftung in Switzerland to identify user needs and user requirements with regard to the CML solution. Following a user-centered design approach, end-users in the CML project are involved in the entire development process and thus participate as co-creators.
From November 28th to December 5th a total of 4 workshops took place in the premises of terzStiftung, each with 4-7 participants.
After a short introduction to the idea of CoachMyLife, the participants had the task to write down important activities of their daily life on cards and place them on a timeline on the pinboard. This was to determine which activities are important in daily life, when they are usually performed and how flexible the CML system should be. In a second step the cards were assigned to rooms using room sketches to find out where these activities are primarily relevant.
Furthermore, the possible challenges/problems related to the performance of the identified daily activities were discussed. Finally, the activities were prioritized according to their importance, which served as a starting point for the development of the system.
With regard to the implementation of CML, the participants agreed that it should be a modular system that grows with the user’s needs. Individuality and flexibility are mentioned as well as reliability and privacy. CML is considered a chance of living longer in one's own home.
However, the workshop also showed that it will be a challenge for developers to meet all user requirements, since activities of daily life are based on individual needs and these cannot be generalized. Each person organizes his or her daily life differently and has different assistance needs, which makes the system very complex. This challenge encourages the CML team all the more to develop a system that creates added value for everyone.
The UMFCD Team participated to the 42nd National Congress of Rehabilitation Medicine, in Cluj-Napoca (Romania), where they presented their research : „Errorless Learning For Cognitively Challenged Older Adults”.
The CML project started in Geneva - Switzerland, where both general and technical coordinators (PPSA & UNIGE) are from.
All partners, coming from Slovenia, Romania and Switzerland, finally met in person. During this journey, they have been working on the CoachMyLife strategy and learned to know each other more.
At the end of their stay, they all went back home, with some swiss chocolate and many promising perspectives.
And so it begins...